Chowhound Presents: Table Talk with Tyler Florence | Ask Your Questions Now ›

Cocktails & Spirits


Bourbon lovers - can someone explain to me why I like Rye much more than bourbon?


Cocktails & Spirits 6

Bourbon lovers - can someone explain to me why I like Rye much more than bourbon?

ncyankee101 | Sep 2, 2010 11:42 PM

I am primarily enamored of Scotch but have tried many liquors this year - aged rums and tequilas, as well as several bourbons and ryes.

Although I really want to, I just don't seem to love bourbon and I am not sure what flavor or combination of flavors are causing the problem.

I have tried a couple I don't mind, namely WT rare breed and Woodford Reserve Seasoned Oak. All the rest I have tried, have been just OK to me, These would be WT 101, Makers mark, JB Black, and Knob Creek. I have also tried Jack Daniels No 7 and Gentleman jack - the latter just was bland to me, sweet up front with no finish at all, just seemed to disappear in the middle of my tongue.

I do like all the ryes I have tried - Wild Turkey, Sazerac and Rittenhouse.

I was hoping someone who knows more about these than I do could tell me what characteristics are shared by the ones I like and don't like - my palate is not yet really able to discern the range of flavors in bourbon. My favorite Scotches tend to be the strongly flavored ones, especially the peat monsters - Ardbeg 10, Laphroaig 10, Also love Highland Park 12.

Oh yeah - forgot to mention, I generally drink them neat, though will experiment with a little water or ice. It has seemed to me that most bourbons when iced leave my mouth feeling rubbery.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound