I hear that people stand in line for hours just to snatch up Garrett’s popcorn from one of its stores in Chicago. Why bother when you can get it delivered right to your home? Surprisingly, the caramel-and-cheese combo is pretty good—I like how the salty and the sweet come together. And it’s made with real butter and cheddar cheese, without anything artificial in it.

Garrett Gourmet Popcorn, $22–$28 for a one-gallon tin

See more articles