It only makes sense for America’s favorite sandwich cookie to imitate America’s favorite sandwich, right? Right. Such is the case with new peanut butter and jelly Oreos, the long-awaited flavor mash-up that somehow slipped through the cracks when gag-worthy iterations like candy corn, banana split, and cotton candy rolled out first.

News of the cookies broke when notorious junk food leaker @JunkBanter posted a shot of the presumed packaging to Instagram on Wednesday.

Though the product has yet to be officially confirmed by Nabisco, it appears that the limited edition flavor will be exclusive to Kroger (which isn’t too far-fetched, considering last year’s Swedish Fish atrocity was also exclusive to the Southern grocery store chain.)

Needless to say, we haven’t been this excited about a new Oreo type since the Pop Rock-heavy Firework variety that debuted this summer. We’re just concerned about the choice in jelly, seeing as there is a huge difference between grape and strawberry (the latter being the best option, obviously).

Taking a page out of Lay’s “Do Us a Flavor” competition, Oreo has also debuted the #MyOreoCreation contest which encourages fans from around the country to submit ideas for new Oreo flavors. Consumers can submit ideas by simply using the hashtag #MyOreoCreation on Instagram or Twitter, with the winner receiving $500,000 and the title of Oreo VIP (aka our dream job). From cannoli and avocado to nacho cheese and tutti frutti, clearly no idea is too out of the ordinary. In fact, a savory Oreo doesn’t sound like the worst idea. It’s all just a matter of texture (which already has us thinking of Combos, for some reason).

Keep doing what you’re doing, Oreo. But by keep doing what you’re doing, what we really mean is stick to the classics and don’t get too creative. We’ll take peanut butter anything over some obnoxiously-flavored fad candy any day.

Related Video: Next-Level Grilled Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwiches

See more articles