Restaurants & Bars

Outer Boroughs Dinner

Weekday dinner for 8 - Carroll Gardens or PS?


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 12

Weekday dinner for 8 - Carroll Gardens or PS?

Sir Gawain | May 14, 2004 11:43 AM

This is something I'm researching for somebody who has a somewhat different set of standards than me, and hence need your help.

This will be a weekday dinner for a group of, I think, 8. The person who is throwing the dinner (which is not a celebration of anything in particular) wants:

- very good food
- ability to have a conversation
- stylish environment (doesn't need to be very formal but a certain amount of style is expected)
- a place with something of a "scene". She wants to feel she's in a "hot", or at least fairly new, restaurant. And she wants to have that "Brooklyn experience", you know...

I thought of the following candidates, but none seem ideal:
Convivium - problem: too rustic (I think)
Chestnut - too small, but maybe. Small wine list though.
Grocery - well, I just can't get excited about it but it's an option I guess
Al di La - would have been great but no reservations, so that's out
Rose Water - decor too informal...
Saul? but isn't that "old"?

I don't know, it's tough. The "scene" aspect throws me in particular, as I tend to avoid places that have a "scene" - but then again, I don't think there IS a "scene" going on at any of these places!

I also considered Blue Ribbon which I've heard great things about, but have never been to. Do you have any other suggestions, or care to comment on my choices? PLEASE, I really do need help.


Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound