+
Home Cooking

Trader Joe's Vs. Libby's Canned Pumpkin - The Results Are In

Kivarita | Nov 13, 200510:59 PM     2

Hi folks -

Just wanted to share the results of the Pumpkin Challenge wrapping up at my house this weekend.

I baked up the second of two pumpkin cakes, this time made with the old stand by Libby's canned pumpkin. Last Sunday was Trader Joe's organic. Used the pumpkin cake recipe, sans honey frosting, from Everyday Food.

Despite having different consistencies straight from the can - Trader Joe's seemed to have less water content and was a slightly brighter color -- the end product wasn't significantly different -- about the same crumb/density and baked in the same amount of time (surprisingly).

Taste-wise, the Trader Joe's version seemed to have a squash-ier, less sweet taste than the Libby's - which I have to guess is based on the variety of pumpkin they use. Both cans claim 4g of sugar. In the end, both tasters in this household preferred the Libby's - I have to think the fact that we've had Libby's pumpkin pie every Thanksgiving in my life has something to do with it.

Anyone else tried this with other recipes? I'd be interested in hearing the results.

Thanks!
Kivarita

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

Support These Black-Owned Bars & Restaurants in Major U.S. Cities
Food Trends

Support These Black-Owned Bars & Restaurants in Major U.S. Cities

by David Watsky | Over the weekend, angst, anger, and unrest over the police killing of George Floyd reached a fever...

22 Black-Owned Culinary Businesses to Support Right Now—and Always
Shop

22 Black-Owned Culinary Businesses to Support Right Now—and Always

by Amy Schulman | Over the past week, the country has erupted in protest over the unjust murders of George Floyd, Breonna...

How to Fight for Food Justice in America
Explainers

How to Fight for Food Justice in America

by David Watsky | What is food justice? We tackle the broad concept of food justice as well as some of the causes of...

Take Pride in Your Cooking: The Best Cookbooks by LGBTQ+ Chefs
Shop

Take Pride in Your Cooking: The Best Cookbooks by LGBTQ+ Chefs

by Simone Paget | There’s nothing quite like the feeling of cracking open a new cookbook and being immediately inspired...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.