+
Home Cooking

Shrimp purchased defrosted vs frozen saute different, need thawing tips for firmness?

TheKnottyHooker | Mar 17, 201709:43 AM     4

Hi. I buy shrimp at a few local grocery stores to *saute once in a while. The ones I buy defrosted seem to cook up with a firmer flesh. I don't overcook them but they get this nice firmness and get a very light char on the outer ridge. Definitely not overcooked but a better appearance and overall texture. When I cook them from a bigger bag after defrosting they're tasty but they lack that specific firmness. I'm not sure that firmness is the right word but it feels like it fits. I rest them on paper towels before cooking so they don't stick to the pan and it helps, but I'd like the firmness I get from grocery store defrosted ones without buying pre-defrosted. Especially since the ones at my local store tend to have black spots. I defrost frozen, usually the same night I buy, using a colander and cold running water. I've Googled, but besides the two very not expanded on references to water-logged, I've found nothing. How do grocery stores thaw their shrimp? Should I leave them in the bag? Or put them in cold (not running) water? Shrimp's kinda pricey and a local discount grocery store has a two pound bag (that I remember buying and cooking in the past with that firmness) on sale. I'd really like to buy some for dinner tonight, but I want them to come out perfectly and unfortunately my memory is poor. I just feel like the last few bags I've bought frozen haven't come out as firm. So, tips?

*Due to heart health concerns I "saute" in just some light cooking spray or a half tablespoon of butter substitute in small batches. (Just enough for one person at a time). I expanded on this term because I know some people don't consider it proper sauteing. Basically a pan on the stove, no added water.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

A Top Chef’s Tips for Keeping It Healthy While Traveling
Guides

A Top Chef’s Tips for Keeping It Healthy While Traveling

by Marisa Churchill | BraunS/E+/Getty Images People...

Tuna Again?! Why You Should Consider Eating the Same Lunch Every Day
Supertaster

Tuna Again?! Why You Should Consider Eating the Same Lunch Every Day

by Grace Gonzalez | If you’re as indecisive as I am, choosing what to eat for lunch every day of the week can be a stressful...

Throw an Italian Aperitivo That Will Put Summer Happy Hours to Shame
Entertaining

Throw an Italian Aperitivo That Will Put Summer Happy Hours to Shame

by Pamela Vachon | The tradition of Italian aperitivo is, by its very nature, a civilized affair. Drinks are light, lively...

Fruit and Cheese Pairings for the Perfect Summer Cheese Board
Guides

Fruit and Cheese Pairings for the Perfect Summer Cheese Board

by Amanda Balagur | Summer fruit is ripe for pairing with all your favorite cheeses, but there are some guidelines to...

See what's new!

View latest discussions ›

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.