Restaurants & Bars

Manhattan In Search Of...

In search of sandwiches, sicilian squares and suggestions


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 30

In search of sandwiches, sicilian squares and suggestions

foodiefrog | Nov 4, 2011 11:48 PM

Hi Manhattan - this is my first post ever to Chowhound!

I make it to your great city about once a year. My spouse, 3-year old and I are visiting from the sticks in California, and we'll be there in a couple weeks for 5 nights. We're staying near Prune in East Village. Given our food-deprived hometown, we make sure we indulge when we're on the road. This year, I intend to focus lunches on great places for sandwiches and Sicilian/square pizza. I'd love to hear your comments on what I'm thinking, as well on the dinner spots for which we have reservations. Dinner rice preference is moderate (roughly 50-60 per adult incl tax and tip; 2 smaller plates or 1 big plate, plus 1 glass wine or beer). Thanks!

Sandwiches (lots of options depending on where we are at lunchtime)
Eggplant Parm: narrowed it down to Parisi and Torrisi. Prefer hot versions vs warm or cold. Heard Torrisi eggplant might not be hot, so leaning toward Parisi.

Italian Combo: Faiccos

Meatball Parm/Sliders: Little Owl, Best Pizza (Brooklyn)

Burger: Little Owl, Shake Shack

Hot Dog: Grays Papaya, Crif Dogs, Shake Shack

Pastrami: Katz

French Fries: Pommes Frites

Falafel: Taim

Sicilian/square Pizza (Been to DiFaras (awesome) and Maffei and Joes (both ok)
Want to try: Artichoke, Best (Brooklyn), Adriennes, Bens?, any others?

Thin Pizza (Been to DiFaras, Joes, Bleecker St, Lombardis, Johns, Nicks-UES)
Want to try: Motorino, Rubirosa, Best

First night (Wed) right after long flight: Walk to Frankie 17. Crostini, cavatelli and ravioli!

Thu (~6PM): Open. Any suggestions? Was thinking Spanish or Indian

Fri: Have 6PM reservation at Rubirosa (for pizza and pasta). Any recs on pasta?

Sat: Have 6PM reservation at Balthazar (daughter loved running around in there last year). I love steak frites. Would consider Le Parisien or Cercle Rouge.

Sun (~6PM): Open. Would like to try Ciano but they're closed. Went to Lupa last year.

Can't wait! Thanks again!!

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound