Restaurants & Bars


Need help reproducing a Lee's Cheltenham Hoagie in Canada


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 14

Need help reproducing a Lee's Cheltenham Hoagie in Canada

looz | Jan 11, 2012 08:02 PM

It's my mom's birthday in a couple of weeks, and I'm throwing her a surprise party with hors d'oeuvres inspired by the various places she's traveled in the past few years. Philadelphia's on the list, and it's a special one - it's also her home town. The food I've decided to replicate (in miniature) is one of her favorite foods of all time - a Lee's Cheltenham hoagie. I'd like to enlist the help of some Philadelphia natives to make it as close to authentic as possible!

According to the Lee's menu, a Cheltenham is a Lee's Special with some added ingredients. From the menu:

All of our Hoagies include Lettuce, Tomatoes, Provolone Cheese,
Seasonings and your Choice of Our Famous Oil, Mayonnaise, Onions and Hot Peppers.

Lee’s Special: Bologna, Beef Salami, Ham, Cooked Salami

Lee’s Cheltenham: A Lee’s Special PLUS Ham, Capocollo, American & Provolone

I have a few questions about this, and hopefully you guys can help me out!

- What makes the oil famous? Is it a special seasoned oil? Olive oil?

- What kind of bread do I use? These are going to be made in miniature, but I don't think mini hotdog buns will cut it.

- Why is ham listed twice? Some other hoagies have "Pepper Ham" on them. Do you think that's what they mean? And if so, what's pepper ham?

- Is there a specific salami I should get for the "Cooked Salami"?

- What can I use for American cheese? I know what it looks like, but the closest thing I've ever seen here in Canada is Kraft singles. If I can find the white ones, will that work? How is American cheese usually sold to the general public?

- Any idea what "Seasonings" they use?

I know this is a long post. Thank you very much in advance! You're going to help make someone's birthday really special.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound