Two Toronto Chowhounds bringing our daughter to New York in celebration of her graduation from high school. We have dinner reservations at The Harrison one night, but are looking for suggestions for good, reasonably priced Italian for another night. Tried to get into Lupa, but no luck. We are staying around 35th and 5th, but are willing to travel for good food. Ideally would like to make reservations in advance (that way nobody gets crabby waiting in line for a table). Any suggestions would be very much appreciated!