This is my first post to Chowhoud, so be gentle.
611 Dorchester Ave.
South Boston, Boston
"It filled a void in my soul that I didn't know I had."
Okay, first of all, I love Polish food. I can't claim any great connection to the Polish people, other than the fact that I have an uncle by marriage who is Polish. Other than that, I was born in Pittsburgh, which has a very large and vibrant Polish-American population.
So when I heard that there was a new Polish restaurant in Boston, my wife and I jumped at the chance. Well, "jumped" isn't quite the word, since it probably took us 10 months to get there (eating out isn't big on the list of priorities for a couple with a new baby), but we finally got out to go there tonight.
And it was fantastic. Incredible. Everything I wanted. It filled a void in my soul that I didn't know I had.
It's exactly what a chowhound searches out-- it is cheap, it is in a neat little hole in the wall place, and it is real food. It hasn't been fancied up (although there are tablecloths on the tables), it is just good.
We started with the house wine and a bottle of Okocim (pronounced "oko-tsim", I think) beer from Poland. The wine was dry and matched the upcoming food well, and the beer was great. And cheap-- $4 for a big bottle (0.5L).
We asked for some bread so that Peter, our 10 month old son, could get a little bit of an appetizer. The bread was unimpressive, but came with a small dish of a spread that seemed to be a combination of lard with little bits of bacon. It was considerably better than it sounds, but I want a bit light on it.
We ordered three dishes: the pierogi plate, the "Polish plate", and the Hungarian Goulash with potato pancakes.
The pierogi plate seems to be a combination of whatever pierogis they are serving that night, and we drawn from (according to the menu): meat, potato, onion, sauerkraut, or fruit. Tonight, we got a combination of meat and sauerkraut. They were fantastic. Obviously very fresh dough, with very flavorful fillings, boiled to perfection, with a bit of drizzled oil and little bits of bacon on top. Wow. If you've only ever had pierogis from the freezer, you just don't know what you are missing. Peter enjoyed the pierogis a lot. $6 for a plate of about 8 pierogis.
The Polish plate included pierogis (again, meat ones and sauerkraut ones), kielbasa, sauerkraut, and stuffed cabbage with tomato sauce. The pierogis were again great. The sauerkraut was very meaty and very good. The kielbasa was just okay-- but I'm not sure what would have made it better. The stuffed cabbage was yummy. Peter actually ate some of the sauerkraut, which surprised my wife, but it wasn't as sour as most commercially prepared (out of a can) sauerkraut. He really liked the stuffed cabbage-- I put a bit on a spoon and fed it to him and he looked at me for more! $8 for the whole plate.
Lastly, though, was the Hungarian Goulash. This was a special that night, so I'm not sure if it is always on the menu. It was nothing like I expected. Take two or three big potato pancakes (freshly cooked, with crispy crunchy edges), and then pour on a smallish amount of a brown sauce with melt in your mouth beef cubes. I was expecting more of a stew/soup, but I quickly warmed to this dish. Highly recommended.
Unfortunately, by the time we were done with the meal, it was already 7:30pm, and that is really getting to be Pete's bedtime, so we were unable to sample any dessert or other after-dinner treats. Total bill-- $35.
If you go: Cafe Polonia is a bit small. There are 4 tables of 4, 1 table of 2, and 1 table of 6. When we got there at 6pm on a Saturday, there were two tables of 4 each available, but it very quickly filled up-- we heard a couple who came at around 7 that there would be at least a 30 minute wait. I think they do take reservations, however, but I'm not sure of the minimum party size. They have beer (mostly eastern european selections) and wine on the menu, but no full bar.
I noticed that they serve brunch on Saturday and Sunday, which sounds great!