What with all the carrying on over the last several posts, it sounds like a lot of us have our brains in Maine. If you're in Metro NY or catch the TIMES online, check out today's dining section and the Maine seafood article by R.W. Apple, Jr. I think he's been reading this stuff here and hasn't given proper attribution.
Re: Cook's on Bailey Island. Uh, huh. Not good. Way better off with non-restauranty more local folks places. Any place that sells t-shirts is at least somewhat to exceedingly suspect.