Restaurants & Bars

Manhattan Expensive

Ns1 reports back: thx NYC, you are awesome but expensive


Restaurants & Bars

Ns1 reports back: thx NYC, you are awesome but expensive

ns1 | Aug 1, 2011 09:23 AM

my list was long and lofty, and I didn't get to cover much. Here is what I was able to try

NYC Pizza - hit up 2 joints

Mario brick fire pizza & Sacco pizza. I was with locals at the time. One is a proclaimed pizza snob. The other is one of the loals favorite joins. General consensus among them was both places were good.

Personally, I found the crust lacking in flavor at both places. Meat pie at marios was too salty. Margharite(sp?) not memorable. 3 pepperoni slices at Saccos, good but also not memorable. I love the style of pizza, but I've had better in LA (vito's, tomato pie). Difaro was way too out there to make a trip just for that.


Was recommended H&H by a local. Also hit up Russ & Daughters. H&H everything bagel, too salty. Russ & Daughters made a proper bagel (ie with tomato, lox, red onionm capers). Not sure it was worth the $45 detour for me, but it was good and I'd go back.

Katz- was almost empty when we got there. Asked for a sample, delicious. But the sandwich? Definitely a purist sandwich. Pastrami was excellent, I couldn't compare it to langers. But in terms of sandwich? Langers. Easily. The #19 is a thing of synergistic. Beauty. I threw away the bread on my Katz sandwich. I would never do such a thing at langers.

Shake Shack - banging burger for me. Wifey felt it was actually too meat heavy (we split a double shack burger). Great sear on the meat, great taste, slightly pink on the inside. A small portion of my patty did not run clear when I squeezed. Great fries (I asked for them well done) and root bear on tap is awesome. But $25 for 2 burgers, 2 drinks, and 1 fry is too much. Not a fast food burger by any means. I would compare this to Taylors Automatic in SF. I'd go back, but this would not be my daily burger.

Momofuku- managed to snag a fried chicken res. 33oz asahi = awesome. Pork buns were awesome, not sure if $9/2 awesome. Onto the fried chicken.. There was 5 of us and we unanimously decided the buttermilk was better. I wasn't sure how the veggies and sauces would play out but I loved it. Of the sauces, the ginger scallion was on a different level of epic. The pancake was too thick. Towards the end, we all had the same style - lettuce, herbs, southern chicken meat, southern chicken skin, ginger scallion sauce. I would say after having Kyochon LA (my la friend who moved to NY says Kyochon la is vastly superior to Kyochon NY) I was not terribly impressed with the Korean chicken. There was a lot of food left: it was a great value, < $200 for all of us.

Anyway, that's all I care to share right now. Thanks for all the recs my fellow NYC hounds. I'll be back to work on the rest of my list.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound