Follow us:

Cocktails & Spirits 6

Novice Manhattan Cocktail Musings

starzzz | Apr 7, 201805:18 AM

I am self-confessed a novice when it comes to Manhattans limited to experimenting at home until I can make the perfect drink (not perfect as in 50-50 sweet/dry vermouth). My intentions is to be able to create a drink that I thoroughly enjoy making and drinking, with the possibilities to also wow guests with the perfect drink!

My tools are as follows:
1 x 600ML Japanese mixing glass with stem
1 x 12” twisted stirring spoon by the Modern Mixologist
1 x no name 15ml/30ml stainless steel jigger
1 x Yukiwa stainless steel Hawthorn Strainer
1 x 4 oz yarai glass cut tumbler from the 70s or 80s
1 x Ultimate Ears Megaboom Blue Tooth Speaker streaming ‘Airline Lounge’ music from my iphone as I mix

My Ingredients are:
2 oz Bulleit Rye Whiskey
1 oz Carpano Antica Formula
2 dashes Agostura Bitters
2 dashes Fee Brothers Orange Bitters
1 x Luxardo Maraschino Cherry on a toothpick
30 sec of right handed stirring with 5 ice cubes measuring 1.5 inches cubed
Infinite amounts of determination

My first attempt at this I found the drink still strong from the whiskey. I thought I changing the ratios between whiskey and vermouth to 1.5 oz each. Outcome:too sweet and no whiskey flavor

Next, I experimented with the amount of time spent stirring creating 4 iterations with stirring at 30 sec, 60 secs, 90 secs and 120 secs. Outcome: the last 2 i.e. 90secs and 120 secs made the whiskey flavor feel washed out.

I am hypothesizing that the key variable here influencing my satisfaction levels is either:
a. Bad technique
b. Not feeling the ambience
c. Choice of Bulleit Rye whiskey
To address a. and b. I plan next time I head to a high end bar or 2 or 3 is to order a Manhattan and note what a purported top notch Manhattan is meant to taste like.

More likely, I will think I will need to vary the whisky. I am thinking next of crossing the red line and making a few iterations from Buffalo Trace Bourbon. It may not be a Manhattan from the perspective of a purist but heck James Bond has his Martini shaken and not stirred.

Other experimentation's I plan is substituting Whisky with Don Julio 1942 Tequila only because I drank something similar with a Mezcal at a fancy South American Bar Restaurant. I have a bottle of Don Julio sitting in a cupboard and it is not going anywhere (short of the sink) anytime soon!
Whistle Pig (back to Rye) may be another option but too expensive to experiment with unless I can get a sample somewhere

My ultimate goal is to be able to say ' this tastes amazing'.


BTW Please don’t preach substitute Bulleit for Rittenhouse unless you have tried both and can tell me why.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Recommended from Chowhound

Catch up on the latest activity across all community discussions.
View latest discussions