Restaurants & Bars


mourning San Luigi


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars

mourning San Luigi

choosieeats | Feb 28, 2008 06:11 PM

what a shame, how disheartening (and quite baffling), that a moderate, neighborhood spot with great food, yummy gelato and congenial atmosphere can't survive! (my faves were the homemade minestrone soup, pounded veal chop capricioso, scallops oreganato and sea bass/various preparations) This was our most favorite casual, spur-of-the-moment place around.

I just called up earlier this evening and got that dreaded beep, followed by the announcement that the number is not in service, no further information...uh oh. So I looked it up on and, sure enough, it was closed, although interestingly, there was a positive review posted there by someone who ate there as recently as 2/22/2008.

So disappointing! Closed without warning, although I must admit that every time I was there, I marveled at the fact that it had survived as long as it did (about 2 years -?- after all was said & done). That location (333 Amsterdam Ave at 75th St or thereabouts) has been notorious for short lived restaurants ever since Gabrielas closed there a while ago.

I want to go out for convenient consistently really good food on the lower upper west side between 68 & 77th, nice atmosphere, without having to book a table weeks in advance (or stand on line half an hour where they don't take res), no special occasion, and without paying $100 to grab a bite for 2. San Luigi was just about the only place around that fit the bill, it will be sorely missed. So why why why can't a place like this survive???

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound