Why havent most people heard of this place? For starters, I have not seen it advertised anywhere. The only place it appears on the internet is on this site and the location is pretty random (although it does remain in Manhattan proper)
We went last night....
I will go out on a limb here and say the overall experience is better than Lugers. The steak may not be as tender as our friends in Brooklyn but the flavor was excellent. The appetizers were pretty much identical as were the sides. (the creamed spinach here may have the edge)
With prices almost exactly the same, a very friendly and competent staff, unless you have never tried Lugers once for the experience....this place is a high recommend chowhounds.