General Discussion

Do you love the concept of organic peanut butter but just hate the mess?

Caroline1 | Apr 18, 201507:44 AM     46

Well, there *IS* a better way than all of that stirring and separating and stirring again. Here's how:

1. ONLY buy organic peanut butter in jars, never in plastic tubs.

2. Stir it well the FIRST time you open the jar to get most of the oil incorporated back into the peanut pulp.

3. Add a tablespoon of (sulpher free) organic molasses and stir again to incorporate.

Let it marry over night, and there you have it! Peanut butter that does NOT separate. '-)

I figured this out by Googling "homogenized peanut butter," (there is no such thing and never has been) and found a whole bunch of different kinds of websites, including one from a "social network" in which a woman (possibly near my age, and back then ALL peanut butter separated!) said that when she was a child, her mother would stir in a spoonful of honey and their peanut butter would never separate again.

Well, I tried that. DO NOT USE HONEY! Honey and peanut butter have a chemical reaction and the peanuts cause the honey to crystalize. Yup. I used honey in my first effort, and thank goodness I only tried it with about a third of the jar. It ended up a lot more like peanut butter penoche than it did peanut butter. And the longer it sat (a day) the "tighter" it got! My current housekeeper is Mexican, and when I handed her a spoon of it to taste, that's what she said: Aha! Penoche de cacahuates! It was no longer spreadable and tore holes in the bread when we tried. So, no honey!

It *IS* the pure cane sugar in molasses that puts the oil and peanuts in suspension. And molasses was the tradition before "Modern Chemistry" began messing with our food. But I can attest that organic molasses does the trick nicely! Next jar I think I'm gonna try pure maple syrup, at least with a little bit to find out if that works. Hey, it may turn out to be a heavy competitor for Nutella! Who knows?

Now, for a final comment, I cannot, for the life of me, understand WHY some company like Smuckers, of Jiff, or Skippy has not figured out they could corner the market on organic peanut butter by simply adding a bit of organic molasses to the product. It would STILL be organic! duh....

Oh, and just for the record, I do not plan on trying corn syrup, Karo or otherwise, simply because corn syrup and/or beet sugar can mess up certain candy and confection recipes, so I'm just not even going to try that route. But if you do, and it works well, let us know!

And Happy organic peanut butter to all of us who want it!

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

How Professional Chefs Throw the Ultimate Thanksgiving

How Professional Chefs Throw the Ultimate Thanksgiving

by Alyssa Jung | Nobody knows how to throw an epic Thanksgiving better than culinary pros and chefs. Which is exactly...

Easy Ways to Make Your Space Cozier for Hosting Thanksgiving

Easy Ways to Make Your Space Cozier for Hosting Thanksgiving

by Jen Wheeler | So, you've agreed to host Thanksgiving (or maybe it's Friendsgiving)! It should be both an honor and...

Vegan Alternatives to Famous Thanksgiving Dishes
Recipe Round-Ups

Vegan Alternatives to Famous Thanksgiving Dishes

by Erin Meister | These vegan Thanksgiving recipes can sneak onto a conventional table or make up their own plant-based...

How to Accommodate Vegan Guests During Thanksgiving
How To

How to Accommodate Vegan Guests During Thanksgiving

by Robin Raven | Thanksgiving is a festive occasion that should be focused on having fun, giving thanks, and savoring...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.