Is there anything that's good but not too expensive in Irvington, NY? I know about Solera and Fuffi (now called Xty, by the way) but they're kind of pricey. I found a place called Il Sorriso but they're also on the high side (although we could probably have a not too expensive meal with their pastas).
Broadway Bar & Grill has a decent rating in Zagat and isn't too expensive, but I can't find their menu online. Remi's is also not that expensive, and actually very convenient for the theatre, but I'm not sure how good it is (Zagat says 16, which isn't a good sign although one of their comments is that it's "getting better"). River City Grille isn't even written up in Zagat and seems to be kind of on the high end based on their web site.
I spent $150 on tickets for the evening so I'm trying to avoid spending another bundle on dinner. Plus there may be a bunch of us meeting before the show, and I'm sure many of them don't want to spend $40 for dinner.