I am looking for a place to hold our wedding rehearsal dinner this summer. We think it will be about 50 people, and we are looking for something low-key, casual and inexpensive (the wedding will be a more formal seated catered dinner). We've considered Otto and John's pizzeria, but the $50 pp price tag for pizza and beer seems a bit excessive for what you are getting.
Our guests are staying in midtown, but if necessary, we can get them someplace else with a shuttle or bus.
I've searched the boards, but found most of the options were out of our price range, and I was hoping someone had a good suggestion of a neighborhood favorite that just happens to do this kind of thing too.
Any help would be much appreciated!