We live in Brooklyn, our friends are in Holbrook, so Huntington-area is a decent compromise. We were talking about maybe Japanese, but she's pregnant so it would have to be someplace with good sushi AND good cooked food.
We're also TOTALLY open to other suggestions - almost any cuisine. What's your favorite place around there? Someplace that's got some atmosphere and will be nice to linger in. My mind has gone totally blank on what restaurants are in that area, so I hope someone can help!