I've just come to a conclusion, after being disappointed by yet another organic, natural, good-for-me brand of PB: I love the old fashioned "bad" kind: Skippy. I love the gloppy, hold-together consistency of the stuff. I love the slightly sweetened taste. I'll try the new Skippy Natural....but I hope it's not too natural. I want the stuff I grew up on.
The latest bad experience was Trader Joe's creamy natural. It was horribly salty, for one, and very very runny. I've had that experience with other "natural" PBs. And no, it wasn't because I didn't stir the oil back in. It was runny. It was horrible.
I refuse to believe that a tiny bit of hydrogenated oil is going to kill me. Long live Skippy. Yum.