We loved Grimaldi's from Day One and I got a lot of flack on this board for saying so. But, I feel compelled to say again, that it's FANTASTIC. Having lived in Manhattan and tasted all the "best", Grimaldi's of GC more than holds its own. The pesto/pepperoni pie is our favorite, with a chopped salad (which is simple, but very tasty). The crust is just charred to perfection and very thin (just the way it should be). Once you try a Grimaldi's pie, frankly it's very hard to go back to a normal pie, which seems so doughy.
Russ, Jennifer, Dean and staff are very friendly, professional and very, very nice. I have to say, I rarely have an experience on the Island anymore like Grimaldi's. And that alone is worth the price of admission...and there's GREAT pizza to boot!
AND NO, THIS IS NOT AN AD!!!