Restaurants & Bars

Outer Boroughs Pizza

Grimaldi's Pizza: not for me


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 12

Grimaldi's Pizza: not for me

Steve R. | Apr 23, 2004 10:23 AM

Hadnt been there in a year or so and the opportunity presented itself last night so my wife and I went. I know that this will seem sacriligous to some but our dinner was almost totally worthless.

Tables were filled by 6:30pm. Looked like mostly tourists, with maps in hand. We didnt want to share an entire bottle of wine so we opted for 2 glasses @ $4.00. We got what we paid for. Shoulda gone for a $25 bottle of chianti and left half over. We ordered one cold antipasta and got 4 slices of mozz. (reasonably good, not great), four thin deli slices of cold cuts (salami?: almost tasteless), 4 large green olives (salty), and lots of marinated red peppers (good, but not better than the ones I can get in jars). That's it for $10. I started missing Christardi's. Then we split one large pizza with onions and mushrooms ($14 + $2/topping = $18). Chewy crust (no coal fired brick oven taste or texture), tasteless tomato topping, decent mozz. cheese (same as in the app.), and a light helping of supermarket mushrooms (fresh, not canned, at least, but not sauteed first or prepared in any way) & sliced onions. Overall, almost without taste. All I can say is that it was filling. My wife and I both think (as incredible as this may seem) that our infrequent antipasto and pizza orders from La Traviata and Buon Gusto on Montegue St. are better! I wouldnt even dream of comparing it to Savoia or Casserta Vecchia.
So...does anyone else think that they're running solely on reputation?

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound