Four of us (Melanie Wong, Ruth Lafler, friend of TDQ) dashed down to Anatolia Gyro after Melanie called ahead Friday morning to ensure that they would have manti. Manti is not on the menu and they make it to order, so you do need to call ahead. We asked for 2 orders; they had 2 ½ orders ready
Tucked in among souvenir shops near the Wharf, Anatolia Gyro is a humble restaurant with a half dozen tables. Clearly run and patronized by Turks, the obligatory blue glass evil eye hangs on the wall above the kitchen and protects the restaurant and its guests. Our gracious server was very attentive throughout.
True to Turkish custom, they immediately served us hot tea in tulip glasses, though they didnt serve them with the two sugar cubes on the side the way I always remembered. Thats okay, there was table sugar if you wanted to sweeten it with the teensy spoon.
Heres what we ordered:
-Ezme (mashed peeled tomatoes, green onion, walnuts, parsley, red pepper sauce, olive oil, and lemon juice) with homemade (flat) bread. More like a weak salsa than the spicier tomato and roasted red bell pepper mixture I was seeking, this dish was my only major disappointment. The red bell pepper would have given it some heft and smoothness. It also wasnt very spicy, so industrious Melanie hopped up and asked our server if they could make it spicier. He brought us a dish of homemade pepper sauce, in which Ruth detected a bit of cucumber. We think. (We were unsuccessful in confirming what was in it--family secret or communication barrier.) We loved the pepper sauce on its own and it did improve the ezme when we added it. Also, we didnt detect any walnuts, which Ruth pointed out would have added richness. Friend of TDQ noted that it would be more satisfying when tomatoes are at their best in summer.
Also, the bread, which is flat and about ¾ inch thick, is wonderfully fluffy on the inside. She baked another batch while we were there and it is worth waiting to get hot out of the oven. In the meantime, they heated up and served us what seemed to be tortillas (I dont think they were gozleme) so we didnt have to go starchless.
-Manti (lamb dumplings in a butter and yogurt sauce.) The wrappers on the manti were tender and silky, in contrast with the lamb inside, which was firm. It wasnt overwhelmingly seasoned or spicy, though the manti were presented alarmingly swimming in butter. Turns out, we all spooned more of that nice sauce onto our plates because it just slides right off the silky wrappers. Manti seems to me to be to be the perfect Turkish comfort food.
-Anatolian Iskender (baked homemade bread cubes with yogurt and tomato sauce topped with lamb gyros and melted butter.) This was very rich and warm and a perfect use of the wonderful homemade bread. Lovely way to take the chill out of a rainy San Francisco day.
-Lahmacun (meat pizza: dough with ground beef, tomatoes, parsley, paprika and black pepper.) You dont know the true meaning of thin crust pizza until youve have the lahmacun at Anatolia Gyro. Crust so thin that even Paris Hilton would be envious, it was crisp without being brittle. The ground beef and tomato mixture was spread equally as thin: Melanie noted that the meat was used almost as a condiment in this dish. We all scooped up the sliced onions they served on the side and sprinkled with __________ (what spice? Ive forgotten. Melanie, Ruth help me out here, please!) and it was amazing, the warm pizza with the crisp onions.
-Baklava Unfortunately, we dont think the baklava was fresh. I thought it was a little soggy, though I was glad that it wasnt as saturated in honey as most.
-Sutlac (oven baked rice pudding.) Served cold, the rice pudding was smooth and silky and refreshing. Not too sweet. Nice way to end a spicy meal.
-Turkish coffee. Melanie ordered it and I didnt try it, but I do love Turkish coffee. She seemed to be enjoying it and, yes, they did sweeten it as part of the boiling, rather than after the fact.
- Yogurt drink (ayran?) Nice, but, goodness, you only need about half of what they serve for one person.
The bill for all of this for four people, including tax and tip, was $60.
2731 Taylor Street (Fishermans Wharf)
Btw Jefferson and Beach
10am-10pm 7 days a week
Melanie, Ruth, please chime in and fill in what I left out or correct me where I'm wrong!
by Hana Asbrink | My latest haul. Welcome to Chow...
by Dan Koday | You ever notice how a great marinade can instantly elevate what otherwise would end up as a pretty...
by Eric Silverstein | By Eric Silverstein Chef Eric Silverstein is the founder and owner of The Peached Tortilla in Austin...
Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.