Hello everyone--I need advice on whether I should take my boyfriend for his 28th birthday to Eleven Madison Park or The Modern (dining room). I assume many people reading this have been to both. I don't want to go overboard on price, but they are pretty much on the same level, I believe. Any recommendations on tasting menus, particular dishes, or advice on atmosphere at either place? Any help would be appreciated. We are both adventurous eaters.
Any suggestions or advice would be helpful--I have reservations at both for 9PM on Friday and need to decide ASAP!