Went there the other night with some friends, and I have to say, this place just isn't great. My friend ordered a milkshake, which was literally the consistency of milk - it must have had hardly any ice cream in it. When she complained, they re-did it and charged her a buck more for a "thick shake" - which was really the consistency of a regular shake anywhere else!
I had the banana ice cream (which didn't taste much like real bananas) with hot fudge (which is too thin and just not as good as it should be.) The whipped cream was good, though.
I like the idea of Eddie's, and certainly the atmosphere, but the goods simply aren't up to snuff. Add to that the surly guy behind the counter yelling at all the servers, and it's just not a fun experience.