Based solely upon food quality and service. Price and atmosphere are not taken into consideration here at all.
For Dinner -
Excellent - Yobo, Lakeview House, Chianti, Vesuvios, River Grill, Blue Martini, Cafe Piti, Canterbury Brook Inn, Cosimo's-on-Union.
Very Good - Schlesingers, Bantas, Loughran's, New Orleans Steakhouse, Youngest Brother, Benvenuti's.
Good - Capri, Havana, Lu-Jos, Napoli's, Gus' Tavern, Villa Italia, Dana's Uptown Grill.
Fair - Painter's, Cena 2000, Itzmi, Il Cenacolo, Torches.
Diners - ranked from Best to Worst.
3. New Windsor Coach
4. Hudson Diner
5. Johnny D's