We've been making a lot of thicker soups / stews recently, like Minestrone, Ribollita; stove-to-oven stuff like Osso buco alla Milanese as well. So I've bought a 26 cm / 5.2 l Staub ECI dutch oven, and by and large I like the results. I also like the looks. It's a quantum leap over the flimsy bargain-bin disc-based SS pots that we have. But
1. It's too small, should've gotten the 28 or even the 32.
2. Quality control is awful (or Amazon is selling seconds). I had to send back two because of pinhead holes in the glaze, even the one I kept has an inclusion. The rim of the lid has a small chip, that might have been me, though I don't see how, as it's been babied.
3. Stuff does tend to burn on the bottom if I'm not extra-careful.
4. It's not remotely even on the bottom. That doesn't matter for sautéing onions, but browning meat, hm.
So, I still want a bigger dutch oven, say 8+ qt, that can do sautéing/browning, then do it's thing for hours on the (gas) stove, in the oven, or both, keeping the temperature even (so not too responsive) and moisture in; but the thought of buying another ECI DO one or two sizes up doesn't appeal.
In theory, I'd say conductive side walls and a heavy lid, either thick straight gauge or fully clad. But fully clad SS, never mind thick and/or in larger sizes, is almost unheard of here in Europe. All I could find is the Demeyere Industry stock pot (more expensive than ECI, going into copper territory); and Spring Brigade. Neither is particularly thick or has a heavy, tight-fitting lid. I can't find any heavy aluminum cookware, not even at restaurant supply stores, much less lined. Copper seems almost counter-productive, unless very thick.
Many veteran 'hounds seem to be ECI sceptics -- but what *is* the ideal vessel to get for the above applications?
by Maryse Chevriere | Food is a major part of my life. I’m more on top of dining and restaurant news than world news. My...
Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.