Oh no! We finally decided to reserve a table at Cookshop for Christmas Eve dinner, but a quick search on this board shows some pretty negative reviews (I post freq. about Brooklyn, so I have come to trust Chowhounds completely). It seems duck and dessert are the only items consistantly praised, and neither of us eat duck.
Other options we considered were Red Cat, Hearth, and Prune. We're thinking cozy, great wines, interesting seasonal menu - and, of course, open and available for Dec. 24.
Is it possible Cookshop has improved, or should we rethink?
As always, thanks!!!