A group of about 6 suburban Moms in our early 40s are having our own late 20th Reunion in NYC. Looking for a place for dinner that will offer something tasty for everyone. We'll be staying midtown east, but will travel to another 'hood. Criteria: inexpensive; accommodate a party of 5-6; somewhere we can hear each other talk - its been a long time and lots to cover! ; a fun spot to harken back to the carefree days ... reservations?? I have been looking at the blogs and got some ideas, but the noise factor is important. Thanks for any help!