I went to City Island for dinner last night for the first time in years--and as I drove down City Island Ave past all of these restaurants--I wondered which ones 'hounds would recommend, if any. I ate at Sammy's Fishbox, which was good. I ordered the broiled sea scallops--which wasn't very risky--and the scallops were fresh and cooked pretty close to perfect. A friend I was with for dinner said that his favorite restaurant on the island is the Crab Shanty. Any suggestions, comments, or stories are welcome!!