Dutch Ovens

Choosing between 2 gifts: Dutch ovens?


Cookware 10

Choosing between 2 gifts: Dutch ovens?

Chaotik_lord | Jan 19, 2013 09:39 PM

Over Christmas, I received two very different items in response to my request for a Dutch oven. One is a Calphalon 7 qt. Kitchen Essentials Anodized aluminum Dutch oven. It is oven safe to 400 degrees with lid.

The other is a Michele B. Cast Iron Lite 5 qt soup pot (an enameled cast iron). It is oven safe to 500 degrees without the lid, but only to 350 degrees with the lid. Additionally, the lid has a steam hole, which seems to counter the purpose of a Dutch oven.

Both lids are glass.

A couple of other things to consider are that I have a soup/stock pot already that I adore, so I don't need the soup aspect so much. I want a Dutch oven for the sealed cooking, and for the stove-to-oven capabilities in particular. Finally, I plan to exchange whichever one I don't keep for a nice cast iron skillet, fryer, or chef's pan.

With all of that in mind...which one should I keep and why? I'm leaning towards the Calphalon if only because of the lid, but will the 400 degree limit be problematic?

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound