We're having an annual mutual birthday dinner (for 6) on March 1st and are having difficulty finding a spot. We're going to be in Blue Point, and we'll travel about a half hour in any direction. One in the group is interested in seafood, but searches keep coming up with places in the Hamptons area only. That's a bit too far.
Price isn't really an object. We switch off, one year in the city, one on Long Island. We've been to the Mill River Inn (disappointing), Barney's (great as always) and Aix-en-Provence (fab as well, as always). Food quality is the key here.
Any suggestions will help. Thanks.