I'm planning a trip in August with 6 friends. 2 are VERY picky, very basic eaters. We're planning one big dinner out (for my birthday dinner) and we'll have one dinner either before or after a show (probably Rock of Ages) one night. Birthday dinner is my treat, I'm less concerned about price because this is a milestone birthday and I've been saving. Some of the "foodie-ier" places will not work for my picky friends. I've thought about steak, but it seems a bit, hate to say it, boring. We're staying on E 34th, but I'd go just about anywhere in Manhattan.
Thoughts for a foodie and her "don't eat anything green" friends?