+
Home Cooking

Advice for fixing my apple butter disaster?

kaitlynmarie | Sep 27, 201502:51 PM    

This is my first time posting here, so I want to say hello, and thanks to everyone here for giving me some awesome ideas while I lurked. Now that I have an account, time for the real questions.

So my friends (who have no canning experience) and i (who grew up canning with my grandma but don't remember too much) bought a bunch of apples, followed the old amish recipe I had, and it just didn't seem right. The stuff never thickened. It turned the right color and looked gorgeous, but it was basically just dark apple sauce with more spices. Everyone told me that it would be fine once it cooled-that it was just the heat making it thin, and to go ahead and can it anyway. I didn't think it was right, but decided that at worst, we'd get apple sauce.

The canning went great, everything sealed and was processed for the correct time for our elevation (we used a boiling water bath canner).

This morning, just for fun, I opened one of the jars and threw it into a saucepan just to see what would happen if I heated it. It turned to apple butter. within minutes (the quickness I'm assuming is because it was so much less apples in the pan than there was previously). I put this in a jar and put it in the fridge, since I know we'll use it within 3 days.

This is where my question comes in. If i open some of the other cans, is it safe to heat them til it's butter and re-can them? I'll obviously wash and sterilize the jars again, and I have new lids for them. and they'll have been in the jars for less than 24 hours. I'm just a bit paranoid since i've heard horror stories involving botulism. Any help here is greatly appreciated.

Thanks!

Also a not so important question, but at the orchard we went to, someone overheard us talking about making apple butter and told us his old family secret is to throw pennies in the bottom of the pot then cook the butter, so the pennies help you stir basically. Now, would the pennies react with the food? Is that safe?! We didn't add the pennies because we weren't sure, but just curious if anyone here had heard of it.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

11 Cocktail Ingredients You Have Hiding in Your Kitchen
Recipe Round-Ups

11 Cocktail Ingredients You Have Hiding in Your Kitchen

by Pamela Vachon | Making a cocktail doesn't have to involve esoteric mixers and nine different kinds of alcohol, as...

How to Make a Fall Herb Garden, No Matter Your Living Space
Guides

How to Make a Fall Herb Garden, No Matter Your Living Space

by Kelsey Butler | Think growing your own is over with summer? Not so. Here's everything you need to know about planting...

9 Ways to Use Your Loaf Pan Besides Banana Bread
Guides

9 Ways to Use Your Loaf Pan Besides Banana Bread

by Camryn Rabideau | With the arrival of fall, baking season has officially recommenced, but if you're not ready for another...

11 Sheet Pan Dinners for Easy Meals with Effortless Clean-Up
Food and Kitchen Hacks

11 Sheet Pan Dinners for Easy Meals with Effortless Clean-Up

by Vanessa Simmons | Need an easy dinner that involves just one pan and hardly any clean up? The choice is obvious: sheet...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.