Follow us:

Explore More Cities › +
Discover the unexpected in Manhattan. Explore All of New York City
Restaurants & Bars 13

1st Time back in NY since 1998 , need restaurant help!

melsy | Apr 19, 200702:50 PM

New to this forum and hope I can get some help, Im a London foody coming with my sisters and mom. We will be arriving next week and have a 5 day itinerary.

Havent been to NY for like 9 yrs (my hubby proposed there). I cant even remember were we ate except for Arthurs Landing in NJ and City Crab on Park Avenue. ( are they any good still ?)

For the 1st night we get there we'd like to have something booked that's quite relaxed after the flight in from London. Somewhere with a varied menu, and good American style (seafood steak etc), casual, middle price range , NOT a typical tourist place, so need help on that !. We'd like somewhere not to far to walk like 5mins or 10 mins cab ride. Were staying at the Gershwin which I believe is round the corner from Macy's ?

We may also be going to an Off Broadway show at the theatre below and dont know were to eat before .

Westside Theatre Downstairs
407 West 43rd Street (Between 9th and 10th Avenues)
New York NY 10036

Fpr another evening my mum wants to go to Tavern on The Green , I dont really know if I fancy it , it looks sorta pretty , but inside seems very old fashioned , any thoughts ?

Need a great , good quality sushi/sashimi place thats medium price point for lunch treat or one in each area , as I have no idea were we will be some days!

Love a good ceviche & ribeye steak, like an amazing Argentinian group we have here in UK.

Price banding I would say no more than $70 a head (+ may be one cocktail !)

1st night casual relaxed informal American fayre
2nd night Seafood
3rd night pre theatre meal
4th night Somewhere modern / stylish and a little buzzy.

Ive got a list below of places we fancy (very eclectic list mind) , but wanted any thoughts on these :

Del Frisco (might be a contender for the 1st night , have no idea were this is situated in the quality , style ratings?)
China Grill
Metrazur etc - any of Charlie Palmer places ??
Oyster Bar - really really want to go , we forgot about it last time
Stanton social
Landmarc in Tribeca
Carmines (upper West side)

look forward to others experiences and ideas

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›
Log In or Sign Up to comment