La Superior, open since August, has quickly become a Williamsburg hot spot for street-style Mexican antojitos. Hounds say tacos are authentic and fresh; carnitas (braised pork) and cochinita pibil (slow-roasted marinated pork) are especially tasty. Also recommended: flautas, gorditas, guacamole, and cactus salad.
“It’s excellent,” promises kbnyca, who singles out the chicken tinga filling for tacos and quesadillas, a standout pulled-meat stew with a thumping chipotle kick. She gives it the edge over the neighborhood competition, Bonita, a block east: “It’s better priced, more consistent, and the chicken is MUCH better-tasting.”
A few blocks away is Taco Santana, already on hound radar for its namesake tacos. chompchomp was unmoved by the tacos (no match for her Brooklyn go-to spot, El Encanto Mexicano) but knocked out by the chilaquiles with chicken tinga. Stewed marinated chicken with peppers, onions, and tomatoes is ladled over fresh-fried tortilla pieces and topped with a complex, fiery green sauce and a sprinkling of queso fresco—“the most mind-blowing, delicious food I’ve had in a long time,” she swears.
Speaking of street Mexican, the guys behind the Calexico carts in Manhattan are going brick-and-mortar in Brooklyn. They plan to open a restaurant in October in the Carroll Gardens storefront where Schnäck once hawked hot dogs and burgers. Calexico’s carts in SoHo and Gramercy peddle hound-endorsed Cal-Mex burritos and tacos, which the owners previewed for Brooklynites on a recent Saturday. Carne asada and black bean tacos were both delicious, reports Puppimus—“Very excited about this!”
La Superior [Williamsburg]
295 Berry Street (between S. Second and Third streets), Brooklyn
Taco Santana [Williamsburg]
301 Keap Street (near Broadway), Brooklyn
Calexico [Carroll Gardens]
122 Union Street (between Columbia and Hicks streets), Brooklyn
No phone available