Tiny, delicate tea sandwiches are primarily found at British afternoon tea, but you needn’t be putting the kettle on to enjoy them, and hounds have lots of tasty ingredient ideas.
Shrimp salad is a classic filling; making it well is all about getting the details right. Use a medium shrimp, recommends alkapal, who thinks they’re sweeter than large ones. Most hounds boil or poach shrimp for salad in the shell in water flavored with some combination of lemon, peppercorns, and herbs.
To your peeled, chopped shrimp, add “a little mayo, minced celery, shallot, S&P, maybe a tiny bit of very finely minced hot pepper, and you’re good to go,” says pikawicca. “I think the real key in any seafood salad is simply to barely dress it,” advises dmd_kc. In addition to using in sandwiches, “try serving in boats made of hollowed-out ripe avocados, suggests pasuga. “Wonderful texture combination.”
On the vegetarian front, smartie says classic cucumber sandwiches are made with thinly sliced white sandwich bread spread with salted butter, thinly sliced English cucumbers, and salt and pepper. “It’s a great sandwich in amongst the other standards of a classic British afternoon tea,” says Harters. But, he adds, “On their own, they’re waste of space.”
Hounds make cucumber variations that hold greater appeal. wineos uses Boursin cheese in place of butter. Others use mixtures of cream cheese, mayo, and grated onion; or cream cheese, garlic, dill, and lemon juice. Refrigerate these mixtures overnight so the flavors marry. LaLa says that, in Kentucky, a spread known as Benedictine is made by combining cream cheese, mayo, grated onion, salt, and drained grated cucumber, and tinting it with green food coloring.