Open water and sugar cravings get the creative juices flowing. The makers of Kayak Cookies say that a trip off the coast of Maine inspired their oatmeal cookies, made with organic oats and flour. They’re enormous, and saltier than you’d think, but—like with fleur de sel caramels—that’s a good thing. Kayak’s cookies are so good we couldn’t pick a favorite; luckily, there’s a mixed bag.

Kayak Cookies Salty Oats, $14.95 for six

See more articles