All featured products are curated independently by our editors. When you buy something through our retail links, we may receive a commission.

With the increasing awareness of how unhealthy refined sugar is, plus the surging popularity of sugar-free diets like keto and paleo, you may be searching for an alternative to processed white sugar. Luckily, stevia is a great natural sweetener well suited for several purposes.

Reducing one’s sugar intake is a fantastic idea, no matter why you’re doing it (to lose weight, to help control diabetes, to save your teeth…), and there are plenty of ways to approach this, but the best and most effective ways of improving your eating habits and making more healthful choices—at least for me—involve solutions that don’t feel like a change; like you’re not really sacrificing anything at all. For example, something as simple as swapping sugar for a natural sweetener like stevia.

Pure Organic Stevia Powder, $16.95 on Amazon

Stevia products often contain additional ingredients, but this is unadulterated.
Buy Now

Related Reading: 5 Sugar Secrets You Need to Know | 13 Easy Ingredient Swaps for Healthier Eating

What is stevia?

For the uninitiated, stevia is a sweetener extracted from leaves of the Stevia rebaudiana plant (which, fun fact, is a member of the sunflower family). The plants are native to Paraguay and Brazil, though are now commonly found across Central and South America, and have been used both as a natural sweetener and for medical purposes for centuries. Apparently, the first person to have studied the plant, back in the 1500s, was a Spanish botanist named Petrus Jacobus Stevus for whom it would eventually be named.

Long story short, here’s why you care: It contains zero carbs, zero calories, and is low-glycemic (a.k.a. it won’t raise your blood sugar levels). Basically, it checks all the boxes. So while you prep your pantry for a sugar purge, here are a couple key things to know about stevia.

Related Reading: This Is Our Favorite All-Natural Sweetener

A little goes a long way.

“The number one thing to keep top of mind with stevia is that when it is an isolated ingredient, stevia is 40 times sweeter than sugar, so it cannot be used as a 1:1 replacement. Being a high-intensity sweetener, only a small amount is needed to replicate the desired sweetness level that would normally be found with sugar,” explains Tara Bosch, founder of SmartSweets, a stevia-based gummy candy company. And actually, the International Journal of Biology found that in some cases, stevia extracts can be up to 300 times more potent than sugar.

Stevia in the Raw, $6.53 at Walmart

This contains stevia and maltodextrin (which is there to cut the sweetness of the stevia and make this suitable as a 1:1 substitute for regular sugar).
Buy Now

Is that…licorice I taste?

The short answer: yes. Consumed in large amounts, or as a powdered form of the raw plant, stevia has a distinct licorice-y, slightly bitter aftertaste.

“In recent years, technology has allowed companies to isolate the naturally sweet parts of whole leaf stevia, removing the unpleasant aftertaste. This process is what results in stevia extract,” notes Bosch.

When manipulated and used correctly, stevia extract can not only imitate the sweet flavor of sugar but also the texture and consistency it lends to confections.

Easy Nutella Brownies recipe


Related Reading: The Best Low-Sugar Cookbooks for Keto, Paleo, and Diabetic Diets

Just because it says it’s made with stevia on the label, doesn’t mean you don’t have to read the fine print.

Because having “made with stevia” on your product’s packaging has proven to be a smart and powerful marketing tool, Bosch warns that it’s important for consumers to read the fine print to make sure they’re not being misled about the contents. “It’s important for consumers to read the label of products that are marketed as being stevia-sweetened, as stevia is also paired with fillers—such as malto-dextrin and erythritol—that can take away from its integrity as a natural sweetener.”

She advises consumers to look closely at where stevia ranks on the list of ingredients—the higher, a.k.a. closer to the beginning, the better. “Many sugar-free products claim to be stevia-sweetened, but actually have sugar alcohols, such as malitol or isomalt, as the primary sweetener.” It’s for this reason, her stevia-based brand, SmartSweets, has zero sugar alcohols, artificial sweeteners, or added sugars.

Related Reading: How to Read (and Understand) a Nutrition Label

Bypass bad-for-you bulk with natural solutions.

“There are stevias on the market that are touted as ‘baking stevias,’ which contain fillers and bulking agents to allow it to function as a 1:1 sugar replacement,” cautions Bosch. “We like to opt for stevia as an isolated ingredient, then add our own ‘bulking agents:’ applesauce, egg whites, or straight-up water are our favorites! A general rule of thumb is that for every cup of sugar you are replacing, you should add 1/3 cup of bulk.” For their part, SmartSweet uses a fiber-based bulking agent so that you can get your daily dose while eating candy—who could ever be mad at that?

Hacking your favorite guilty pleasure treats with stevia is easy.

For example, Bosch recommends that next time you want to hit up your local coffee spot for your favorite blended iced beverage (or PSL now that we’re getting cooler…), ask the barista to make it unsweetened and (obviously) skip the whipped cream. Add a pinch of stevia and—boom—your favorite Starbucks sipper is now guilt-free (but doesn’t taste like it). And for a perfect, decadent but not indulgent dessert, she likes to layer plain Greek yogurt and fruit dusted with a little stevia to create a sugar-less fruit parfait.

Related Video: Agave Is Another Healthy Sugar Swap

Header image courtesy of Shutterstock.

Maryse Chevriere is a certified sommelier, James Beard Award winner for @freshcutgardenhose, and author of "Grasping the Grape," a no-nonsense but really fun guide to wine.
See more articles