Sometimes you just don’t want two dozen cookies, or an entire cake or pie—or at least you don’t want to tempt yourself with the surplus—so what to do? Learn how to make dessert for two with these conversion tips for scaling down recipes and ready-to-go small-batch dessert recipes from a pro: Christina Lane, who literally wrote the book (more than one, actually) on the subject.
When a craving overtakes you, sometimes you have to satisfy it. We get it. You can’t stop dreaming of rich, fudgy brownies cradling crystals of fleur de sel; moist pound cake bursting with lemon sunshine, caressed by a dollop of fresh whipped cream and crowned by glittering berries; or smooth, yet intense, hazelnut gelato, so sultry on the tongue you wish it would never end. These sweet, decadent, and sometimes forbidden foods are salacious in and of themselves, whether it’s Valentine’s Day or not. You can swap in healthier ingredients, which helps, but the real trick is to make this dessert an exclusive, one-night-only engagement for you and your plus-one.
Christina Lane knows how to make that magic happen. She wrote the cookbook “Sweet & Simple: Dessert for Two” to share her favorite desserts in the easiest recipes possible that make enough for only two people, so there are no leftovers to tempt you in the morning.
Sweet & Simple: Dessert for Two, $27.84 on Amazon
Perfect portions of delicious desserts.
“If you’re going to make a whole pan of brownies, you might eat the whole pan of brownies. We’ve all been there,” says Lane. While all her books are about small-batch cooking, this third cookbook is more laser-focused on her personal passion for fruity over chocolatey desserts, and uses shortcuts like store-bought pie crust to keep it simple. (“Comfort and Joy: Cooking for Two” focuses more on small-scale savory recipes if you need dinner inspiration.)
Lane hatched the Dessert for Two blog that started her small-batch success in 2010. She was a Dallas transplant in northern California, working in greenhouse production after earning her master’s degree in horticulture. “I had too much time after getting off work at 3 p.m.,” Lane says. “I was away from home and my family, so I found myself calling my mom for family recipes like Texas chocolate sheet cake, which I learned to scale down. I’d crave her desserts.”
When she found a tiny cake pan at a store, Lane had her eureka moment. “I thought, ‘This is it! I get to eat what I love in small-sized versions.'”
How to Make Dessert for Two
Try your own dessert for two on Valentine’s Day—or any day that ends in “y”—keeping these tips in mind:
1. You don’t have to run out and scour stores for adorable mini baking dishes. Maybe eventually you’ll want to do that, but there are many small-batch desserts you can make with the dishes you already have in your kitchen, such as a bread-loaf pan for baking two large brownies, a muffin tin for mini pies, and ramekins for the rest.
USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Loaf Pan, $13.99 on Amazon
Make one loaf of bread—or two generous brownies!
Wilton Recipe Right Muffin Pan, 12-Cup Non-Stick Muffin Pan, $7.10 at Walmart
Make mini pies, sweet or savory, in your muffin tin.
Bellemain Porcelain Ramekins, 6 for $12.95 on Amazon
Perfect for individually portioned desserts of all kinds.
2. When you are ready to buy mini bakeware, try Sur La Table, Amazon, Michael’s, or other craft and cake-decorating stores. The first thing to get is a 6-inch cake pan that’s 2-inches high. Don’t get the 3-inch-high pan, which will make the cake sink.
Wilton Perfect Results Round Mini Cake Pan, $4.97 on Amazon
The ideal size for smaller cakes.
3. “Make sure your baking soda and baking powder are not a decade old,” Lane says with a laugh. (But she’s serious, and it’s good advice; you don’t want your efforts to fall flat.)
Related Reading: What Is the Difference Between Baking Powder and Baking Soda?
4. Learn how to split uneven numbers of ingredients. Lane doesn’t give advice on doubling or tripling her small-batch recipes, but when she’s testing how to create small versions of regular-sized recipes, she starts by cutting all the ingredients in half, and comparing that result with the taste and texture of the full-sized dessert. When she needs to split an uneven number of eggs, she has a rule. If the original recipe called for three eggs, she’ll use two egg whites and one egg yolk for cakes, and two egg yolks and one egg white for brownies and cookies. Cakes can use a fluffy binding agent like egg whites, and the fat-filled yolk makes brownies and cookies that much more intense.
5. Know when to use Silpats and when to use parchment. “I like Silpats (the baking mat) because they keep cookies from spreading too much,” she says, “although in my book’s second recipe (easy chocolate-hazelnut cookies), I want them to spread and get crispy on the edges and gooey in the middle, so I use parchment.”
AmazonBasics Silicone Baking Mats, 2 for $13.99 on Amazon
Related Reading: How to Get the Greasy Film Off Old Silicone Baking Mats
Valentine’s Day Desserts for Two
For Valentine’s Day, Lane plans to make her cherry dessert with the pie-dough hearts from the cover of her book. But she recommends staying with chocolate, like a chocolate pot in those mini crème brûlée ramekins, similar to chocolate molten lava cake. (While we’re on that subject, learn the difference between semisweet and bittersweet chocolate, find out what chocolate percentages actually mean—and check out our chocolate recipes, whether you try scaling them down or not. Maybe one of our 11 Luscious Chocolate Cakes for Valentine’s Day will strike your fancy, or something from our Mexican Chocolate Menu…)
“Chocolate is the classic thing to do for Valentine’s Day. It just feels right,” Lane says. Here are three other sweet ideas from Lane’s book:
It doesn’t take much more than some coconut milk, gelatin, figs, and honey to make this delicacy come to life. It’s also dairy-free and naturally sweetened. Do this dessert ahead of time though, because it needs at least four hours to set in the fridge. Get the Coconut Panna Cotta recipe. (If you want to make it vegan, use agar-agar instead of gelatin and agave or maple syrup in place of honey.)
Crunchy, sweet, and nutty, toffee is the thing. Similar to Lane’s panna cotta, this sweet treat requires about four hours to set but you only need a few ingredients to make it happen: almonds, chocolate chips, salt, sugar, and butter. Get the Easy Toffee recipe.
If you can buy a couple slices of pound cake and a tiny carton of sorbet, it won’t take long to make this classic dessert that whips up chills, in a good way. Get the Easy Baked Alaska recipe.
And if you only need dessert for one, Easy Mug Cakes are the perfect solution!
Get more great Valentine’s tips, tricks, and recipes (plus other Valentine’s Day gift ideas) at our Valentine’s Day headquarters.
This post was originally published in 2017 and has been updated with new links and text.
Header image courtesy of Dessert for Two.