Lobster Pot Pie

Sign up to save this recipe to your profile Sign Up Now ›
2 Ratings 

Ingredients (7)

  • 1 cup diced lobster (or another protein such as chicken/turkey/shrimp)
  • 1 cup of veggies all diced to similar size- combo of corn, peas, carrots, potatoes, celery, leeks, onions (your pick but I like pearl onions, leeks, carrots, corn and potatoes)
  • 1/4 cup heavy cream (or milk, but reduce the stock and add more milk)
  • 1/2 cup chicken stock (can substitute with broth or beef/veggie stock)
  • 1 tablespoon dijon mustard
  • Puff pastry (I always buy mine)
  • salt and pepper to taste
Try Amazon Fresh

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.

Lobster Pot Pie


Just like chicken pot pie, except with lobster. I thought I’ll give this a twist and splurge with lobster. It turns out it’s not a very good idea. I first found this recipe using cream and a touch of dijon mustard. The rest of the recipe is the same as every other one, chopped veggies and protein, cook till done and bake. The cream keeps the chicken moist and the gravy thick without needing starch. The mustard gives it a tang that isn’t easily attributed to mustard but certainly make it more flavorful and eat a second serving. I use a mustard with horseradish that gives it even an extra kick.

I always use puff pastry on top because I love puff pastry. So I added the lobster at the last minute and poured everything into the casserole and sealed it with puff pastry. The puff pastry takes at least 20 mins in the oven because it needs to dry out and puff up. That is too long a time to cook lobster. Had I use chicken or even a high oil content fish it would have been ok. But to a picky eater like me, I like my shellfish moist. So it was good, but the slightly dehydrated lobster (even the think creamy sauce didn’t save it) kept it from being great.

I’m glad I didn’t line the bottom with puff pastry too, it would have turned out to be a soggy mess. Note to self, puff pastry stays on top where it can dry out. Soggy puff pastry tastes like elmer’s glue…bleh. It was so chewy I couldn’t swallow it.


  1. 1Saute the veggies in oil or butter, season with salt and pepper. It’s important to get some of the moisture out or the liquid will be too watery later. Add the stock and cream and simmer to desired consistency, it will reduce and become thicker. Add the protein. I turn off the heat at this point because it will cook in the oven and don’t want to dry it out. Pour everything over a casserole and cover with puff pastry in one layer. If you have extra, do not put on another layer, more isn’t definitely not better in this case. Bake according to puff pastry directions. I use 375 degrees for 20 mins for mine.
  2. 2Variations–if you are using shellfish, add some old bay seasoning and tabasco!
Load Comments

Recommended from Chowhound

These Christmas Cookie Cutters Are Festive AF

These Christmas Cookie Cutters Are Festive AF

by Jen Wheeler | Christmas cookies come in all shapes, sizes, flavors, and guises, but cut-out sugar cookies are some...

How to Pull Off a Perfect Holiday Brunch Potluck

How to Pull Off a Perfect Holiday Brunch Potluck

by Amy Sowder | There are lots of festive ways to pull off a holiday party, but a brunch can be especially nice since...

Chowhound Gift Guide 2019: Decanters for Every Occasion

Chowhound Gift Guide 2019: Decanters for Every Occasion

by Pamela Vachon | Decanters for your wine or whiskey this season help to elevate mere libations into occasions. More...