I am surprising my wife, and taking her to dinner this Saturday night in honor of our seven-year wedding anniversary. I currently have reservations at Estela and Vinegar Hill house. We have not been to either place. We eat everything, do not have a cuisine preference per se, and location/price should not be considered. We tend to prefer more casual restaurants (i.e., my wife did not love the stuffiness of the dining room at Blue Hill at Stone Barns), but I want my decision solely based on where would you rather eat dinner. Any input on which I should choose? Thanks in advance!