We get a lot of these "The Single Most Underrated Dish" or "The Single Most Overrated Dish" topics that generate a list of dishes, and a thread of discussion for each listed item. These are entertaining if the participants stick to the topic of the threaded post [e.g., kebabs]. The indentations in the topic responses are the website's signal that threaded discussions are the way to go.
Then there are those who just post a list of everything they can think of, in a single post, which stymies discussion. I don't enjoy those posts.
I've participated in forums on other websites that ban topics that result in just a list, for the reason that the forums should generate discussion.
DON'T list everything you can think of in response to the topic.
[Lobser, Crabcakes, Fried Fish, Shrimp, Scallops, Clams, Oysters]
DO reply with one response you feel most passionate about.
[I love a well-seasoned Crabcake; Old Bay is my favorite.]