I'm taking a friend from out of town to dinner tonight, and would like to treat him to someplace really nice. Price is no object, but it has to be reasonably casual (we'll be dressed well, but probably in jeans) and it should ideally be in midtown (east or west).
I was thinking Judson Grill, but I seem to remember it being a bit dressier than we'd like. Can anyone confirm or deny this recollection? Two other considerations: my friend is allergic to seafood, and we most likely won't have a reservation. Thanks in advance for your suggestions!