Explore More Cities › +
Discover the unexpected in Outer Boroughs. Explore All of New York City
Restaurants & Bars 10

How do you get your steak cooked at Luger's?

steakrules85 | May 30, 200809:44 AM

Hey all just trying to get a little poll going here on how you all order your steak at Luger's. I for one have been there three times and have gotten it medium rare everytime with a nice crust on the outside (because I share with my dad and he doesnt like it to be too rare).

However, this time since my father will not be with me I am considering getting it cooked rare. I really love my steak in between rare and medium rare with a nice charred crust. But I tried asking for this once and the waiter kinda looked at me funny. So I just told him gimme medium rare, but a little less than that.

I am just worried that if I just order it plain rare its gunna come out purple and cold which I really don't care for. I like it to be more DEEP RED with a charred crust. And yes, I know that the steak tends to cook a little more as it sits in the beautiful sizzling juices. So how do you all get it cooked and what are your experiences when ordering rare specifically?

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›
Log In or Sign Up to comment