+
Home Cooking

Help me solve a baking mystery

maestra | Aug 8, 201909:20 PM     20

Okay, how about this one. I've been making this brownie recipe for years: https://www.epicurious.com/recipes/me...

Totally my favorite. I get asked to bring these brownies to gatherings. In the last few months a young aspiring baker in our friend group asked me for the recipe. I happily shared, and told her little tips for success.

Her family told me her brownies never turn out like mine. Rather than being chewy and rich, they're cake-like. After several failed attempts in two houses, it was decided that I would come over and prepare them with her. We'd find out what was going wrong.

At the last second, I decided to bring all my supplies (except flour) from home to make a side-by-side control batch. My batter looked just like it always does. Hers looked similar. Then we baked.

BOTH batches of brownies came out cake-like -- one could even say dry and crumbly! Mine have never turned out like that.

The problem can't be the oven, because she was getting the same result with two different ovens in two different homes.

We used slightly different ingredients (I had theorized, for example, that part of her problem was that she was using natural cane sugar with large granules instead of white sugar), but the result was the same texture. I brought the pan I always use.

What happened?

King Arthur Flour Fudge Brownies

www.epicurious.com
King Arthur Flour Fudge Brownies
Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

10 Trader Joe’s Products Nutritionists Swear By (Including Snacks!)
Guides

10 Trader Joe’s Products Nutritionists Swear By (Including Snacks!)

by Anna Hecht | It’s easy to beeline right for the peanut butter cups and frozen food at Trader Joe’s (not to mention...

Friday Fish Fry Recipes From Around the World for Lent
Recipe Round-Ups

Friday Fish Fry Recipes From Around the World for Lent

by Daphne Chen | Calling all seafood lovers! Whether or not you observe Lent, you'll want to try these delicious fried...

Sonoko Sakai Wants to Teach You About Real Japanese Home Cooking
Table Talk Podcast

Sonoko Sakai Wants to Teach You About Real Japanese Home Cooking

by Hana Asbrink | Welcome to Chowhound's Table Talk podcast, where Executive Editor Hana Asbrink chats with some of...

This Pineapple Upside-Down Cake Comes with a Poignant Story
Food News

This Pineapple Upside-Down Cake Comes with a Poignant Story

by Amy Schulman | In the many decades that journalist and activist Toni Tipton-Martin watched the media cover African...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.