dougbma50 | Sep 16, 201910:11 AM     14

I smoked a brisket this weekend and it was very dry. In the past I have had different levels of success although they never really turn out super moist. I am using a smaller RecTec pellet smoker which I know is not the choice of BBQ chefs but it is what it is. Here is what I did:

1. Started with a 7lb brisket flat (USDA Angus)
2. Injected the brisket with a beef broth in a 1-1.5 inch grid. The needle is relatively large, say 1/8" or slightly smaller.
3. Dried it and then applied 3 levels of rub, (Salt, Pepper, Garlic power), (Harry Soo's Moola Beef Rub), (Montreal Steak Seasoning). I will add that the flavor was great.
4. Put it in the fridge at about 8PM.
5. Pulled it out at 4AM and let it sit on the counter for 1 hour while the smoker warmed up to temp.
6. Put it on the smoker at 5AM (250°) and didn't touch it. I did have a tray of water in the smoker as well.
7. Checked it at about 10:30 and it was around 168° which surprised me that was that high after that short a period of time. My last brisket, about the same size took nearly 12 hours.
8. I wrapped it in pink butcher paper and put in two probes but this time one read nearly 180 and the other around 170 in different areas of the meat.
9. I monitored them up to 202 and pulled it off (around 2:00). While I didn't watch it the entire time, it seems like it never stalled. Maybe way too lean?
10. Left it in butchers paper and wrapped it in two towels and then put it in a cooler and left it to rest until dinner was served, shortly after 8:00. Did I leave it to rest way too long (6 hours)? What's the option? Couldn't change the party and have people come at 4:00.

I just didn't feel good about how fast it cooked. In the past I would cook at 225 but was concerned because the last one took 12 hours and it seemed that people were getting great results at 250 as well. The probe did go in like butter but the entire brisket just felt way too ridged. In the past it would fall over my hand and I've seen plenty of videos where they would jiggle but this one did not, at all. That said, I check all over and it was at between 200 and 203 everywhere so it was done. The flavor was fantastic as was the smoke ring and it cut very smoothly but not a drop of liquid anywhere. In the past I have seen people cook to 190 and the brisked is very dry and tough so I have always gone to 202-203 and it definitely renders and sometimes there's a bit of moisture but more often it ends up on the dry side. The previous brisket was from Whole Foods and while I don't recall the price, I'm pretty sure it was over $100. This one was $50 at Big Y.

Any thoughts/advice?


Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

15 Canned Sardine Hacks for a Better Snack
Test Kitchen Notes

15 Canned Sardine Hacks for a Better Snack

by Chowhound Editors | If you're unsure how to eat canned sardines, we have some intriguing ideas for you. Usually tinned...

The Shocking Truth Behind the Triscuit Name Revealed on Twitter
Food News

The Shocking Truth Behind the Triscuit Name Revealed on Twitter

by Jen Wheeler | I love learning about the genesis of odd food names (and words in general), so the recent revelation...

The Care & Feeding of Your Sourdough Starter

The Care & Feeding of Your Sourdough Starter

by Heather Reid | Sourdough is having a moment—many people are hunkering down at home and embarking on new projects...

How to Nail Your Next Virtual Happy Hour or Dinner Party 
How To

How to Nail Your Next Virtual Happy Hour or Dinner Party 

by David Watsky | Staying in is the new going out—at least for now—and we've some fun ideas for making the most of your...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.