+
Wine

Can screw-top wines spoil or go bad?

MichelinStarChaser | Aug 26, 200805:48 AM     55

I was dining at a "trendy" Toronto restaurant on the west side last night.
I was drinking wines by the glass with dinner. I had one glass of Pinot Noir and then wanted to switch. The bartendress opened a new bottle of a different Pinot Noir for me (but one I had had before - Six Foot Six from Victoria). From my first sip, it just smelled bad and tasted bad. When I mentioned this to her, I was surprised at her reaction - she said, "Oh, this is a screw-top and it's a new bottle, so it couldn't possibly be bad." What ever happened to "the customer is always right?!" Ha-ha. I was surprised, because I hinted that perhaps my taste buds were be-fuddled by my meal and someone there should give it a sip, and that's what I would have done if I were working behind the bar, just to check!
I left the $14 glass unfinished (a BIG hint that somehow went unnoticed), paid my 100-dollar tab plus a nice tip, and left.
So...if it's possible, it must be quite rare, but can screw-top wines spoil, oxidize or go bad?
Thanks!

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

How Professional Chefs Throw the Ultimate Thanksgiving
Entertaining

How Professional Chefs Throw the Ultimate Thanksgiving

by Alyssa Jung | Nobody knows how to throw an epic Thanksgiving better than culinary pros and chefs. Which is exactly...

Easy Ways to Make Your Space Cozier for Hosting Thanksgiving
Guides

Easy Ways to Make Your Space Cozier for Hosting Thanksgiving

by Jen Wheeler | So, you've agreed to host Thanksgiving (or maybe it's Friendsgiving)! It should be both an honor and...

Vegan Alternatives to Famous Thanksgiving Dishes
Recipe Round-Ups

Vegan Alternatives to Famous Thanksgiving Dishes

by Erin Meister | These vegan Thanksgiving recipes can sneak onto a conventional table or make up their own plant-based...

How to Accommodate Vegan Guests During Thanksgiving
How To

How to Accommodate Vegan Guests During Thanksgiving

by Robin Raven | Thanksgiving is a festive occasion that should be focused on having fun, giving thanks, and savoring...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.