Landed at MacArthur yesterday and of course had to scarf a few slices at Scibelli's...
Previous poster had rec'd the Grandma slice... it was very good, less dough and more topping than a typical sicilian. Also tried the lasagna slice which was well done but basically a pretty bland heap of hambburger. The white slice was predictably bland.
My faves there remain the basic slice, the pesto, the sicilian, now the grandma... the chicken slices LOOK great if you're into chicken slices. The traffic here seems to be picking up, think the word's getting out.
I love this place! just give me the plain slice and I'm good to go.