+
Cookware

Roasting pan - Material and covered or not

ipoulk | Apr 15, 202001:58 AM     15

Hello,

I would like to ask for your help as I don’t have extensive experience with roasting pans and I need to buy one. My aim is to roast kid leg/shoulder, pork , chicken (I sometimes add potatoes with lemon and olive oil/butter) and have the best possible result, juicy well cooked meat. I would like to get one to keep forever.

To my understanding, the material of the roasting pan is not crucial because inside the oven the pan is hit by heat from all sides. Is that true?

What is the difference then between a ss roasting pan, a copper roasting pan or cast iron one? ( I didn’t include porcelain/glass on purpose.)

And, if the roasting pan (regardless of the material it is made of) is covered with a lid or baking sheet&Aluminium foil, then it is a Dutch oven, right?

So will the result of roasting a kid leg in a Staub cocotte with lid be the same as roasting the same in a copper or ss roasting pan with lid?

Is roasting covered or uncovered a matter of taste or is there a right or wrong?
To my understanding, roasting uncovered requires more attention and care. Because the meat has to be turned and basted in order to achieve the desired internal temperature. Does it also need to be elevated?
Whereas when “roasting” covered , heat and juices are trapped inside which makes the meat anyway juicy without the need to turn it or do anything. Plus the oven remains clean. Is that right?

These are my thoughts, if you have any input or comments or anything to say on those, it would be very helpful!

Thank you!

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

Birria Red Tacos Prove Soaking Your Tortillas Is a Genius Move
Food Trends

Birria Red Tacos Prove Soaking Your Tortillas Is a Genius Move

by David Klein | Learn how to make birria tacos at home and you’ll never go back to your usual naked tortilla. A taco...

The Unassuming Ingredient That Stands Between You and Perfect Salsa 
Food Trends

The Unassuming Ingredient That Stands Between You and Perfect Salsa 

by David Watsky | Making fresh salsa at home is easy and the result is a versatile snack perfect to eat plain with chips...

These Easy One Pot Meals Minimize Kitchen Messes
Food Trends

These Easy One Pot Meals Minimize Kitchen Messes

by Greg Stegeman | When it comes to an easy dinner, it's hard to beat one pot meals—below, an ode to the one pot dinner...

The Ultimate Guide to Cleaning & Decluttering Your Space
Home

The Ultimate Guide to Cleaning & Decluttering Your Space

by Chowhound Editors | Whether you get super excited about spring cleaning or the very thought makes you want to go back...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.